Situation A
A first-year medical student in California whose personal blog is hosted by a large weblog content provider posts explicit directions on facilitating an assisted suicide in the interest of “serving the rights of competent, terminally ill adults.” Is this legal? Is it ethical? A teenager in another state who is being treated for depression reads the post and succumbs to a fatal, self-administered overdose of drugs, crediting the blogger for “helping her do it right” in her last note to her family. Who is responsible for the tragedy? The teenager herself? The medical student? The weblog content provider for allowing the blog content to be posted? The parents for not monitoring their emotionally fragile child’s Internet access closely enough? What, if any, crime has been committed and who can and should be prosecuted?
Comments:
The assisted suicide is not legalized in California, so if the medical student is judged as "assisting", it's not impossible that he would be found guilty. But was he really assisting? In the case of "assisted suicide", the "assist" is defined as the consensual help that one offers in response to the suicidal person's request. If the teenager asks medical student for the drug prescription and he consented, then he is assisting. We can imagine another scene; the teenager was searching the keyword "suicide drug prescription", and the blog of the medical student is the first result he saw and tried. In this sense, we can joke that the legal responsibility of the medical student depends more on his karma. This scene is of course just one of many possibilities, but the point is clear: it is not the information-provider's fault if someone takes the information and uses it for a different purpose. It's the similar reasoning as the maker of a sword cannot be found guilty because the sword is used by someone else as a murder weapon. The medical student is protected under Free Speech Law.
The web provider cannot be blamed either, because the web provider does not hold the responsibility for the individual's act. As it is virtually impossible for parents to monitor everything of his children, parents are not to blame, either.
It's almost impossible to tell whether medical student's act is ethical. The ethical issue of assist suicide has been hugely debated, and each side has sound reasons, so I would not elaborate on this topic. But I would suggest this medical student and people alike to take account of the potential risk and be careful with the information they provide.
Monday, September 30, 2013
Thursday, September 26, 2013
Excel Linda.com
Every video is very clear, conversational, sometimes funny, and nothing is confusing. I learned some convenient tips for pasting, knew the difference between function and formula and put in the time that changes with current time,etc.
Monday, September 23, 2013
copyright presentation
At April this year, I installed two chairs in the grassy area near the pregnant woman statue for three hours, I sat in one of them while anyone can sit opposite me, and we stare at each other's eyes in our utmost presence. This is the performance art that I made for my art design class, and it had an unexpected and heartfelt effect on both me and my audiences. Wait a second? what are you talking about? Well, I know we the topic is copyright. Just like your reaction, I never associated my performance with the copyright infringement before last EIT class.
my experience of Copyright by Will Lin is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported License.
This performance art is called Artist is Present, originally performed by Marina Abramovic. According to law, the copyright law first takes effect over an intellectual work when it is fixed in tangible medium, which pushes me to the verge of copyright infringement. But in my case, it's trick to tell whether I violated the rule or law. While it's virtually impossible to get permission from Marina Abramovic, I have two factors that may justify myself.
The first factor is whether it's my own content. Everything becomes ambiguous and trick in the art. While the form of my performance art was inspired by and identical with that of Marina, it's largely different. Now I understand why the art professor asked me to write a paper to address differences between mine and Marina's. In that paper, I drew seven sound differences.
The second factor is whether I am under fair use. Marina's art is a spiritual and educational work, and my intention was the personal experience, in another word, the self-education. The nature of original work and copying is far from profitable.
Jason commended copyright as the stimulus to the intellectualism,but the confusion of whether an copy is infringement and the strict rule of infringement can prevent people from the experience and learning. For example, if I knew my performance art was on the verge of infringement beforehand, I may re-consider whether to do it and probably missed the profound experience.
my experience of Copyright by Will Lin is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported License.
Wednesday, September 18, 2013
Monday, September 16, 2013
Using Lynda.com
I just checked out "Using a Table to organize text and graphic" in Linda.com. The voice and delivery is clear. The problem is that the speaker spends too much time in stressing one particular technique, but after all, the tutorial videos are designed step by step for the beginners; and I could always drag the progress bar to improve the efficiency.
I prefer to study as a group in the class, because the technical tutorial is often boring, yet the instructor in the class knows how to educate without losing the entertainment.
Wednesday, September 11, 2013
My Trinity Network Diagram
The 20 minutes tour in the control room showed us behind the taken-for-granted network service, there is a complex yet well-organized system and hard-working managers!
Monday, September 9, 2013
NETWORK SERVER DIAGRAM
Within Trinity Network, there are many services diagrams and three of them are most commonly used by students: Y Drive, Class Drive and Group Drive.
Wednesday, September 4, 2013
Best Tech Tips
Mr.Ender shared his experiences on the basic tech survival tips, and those are the experience that would not be taught through the normal classes but are very helpful to our study and life.
Firstly, the download and copyright issue. China is a country that we could download as much music, books, apps, movies as we want. This is a cultural different that would literally cost a lot if I am not careful.
Secondly, ITS center offers the free service on our laptops, and even repair the iPhone!
Thirdly, right after the class, I equipped my laptop with Microsoft, C-Cleaner that are offered and recommended.
Fourthly, he gave some many other tips. Like clean our recycling box often; recommend Ninite.com that provides the one-time download of the most common applications.
Thank you Mr.Ender!
Firstly, the download and copyright issue. China is a country that we could download as much music, books, apps, movies as we want. This is a cultural different that would literally cost a lot if I am not careful.
Secondly, ITS center offers the free service on our laptops, and even repair the iPhone!
Thirdly, right after the class, I equipped my laptop with Microsoft, C-Cleaner that are offered and recommended.
Fourthly, he gave some many other tips. Like clean our recycling box often; recommend Ninite.com that provides the one-time download of the most common applications.
Thank you Mr.Ender!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)